jle Logo

building in Mallorca and the Balearics checklist

online jle checklist

New Build, Conversion or Refurbishment in Mallorca

Many projects in Mallorca do not begin with an empty plot but with an existing house. The fundamental question then arises quickly: is the existing building worth keeping, or does a clean start make more sense? The right answer does not depend on gut feeling but on substance, documentation, the idea for use and the target picture.

The decision between a new build and refurbishment in Mallorca is not a question of style. It is legal, technical and economic. A new build creates clarity. A refurbishment demands a precise assessment of the existing building. (Web GOIB)

The same principle applies to both routes. A visible building and a building that is secure in planning-law terms are not the same thing. With older houses, fincas and extended existing properties in particular, it must be checked before any decision whether documentation, substance and the idea for use fit together. The current reforms have opened special routes for certain time-barred cases. They have not, however, abolished the basic duty to assess the existing building. (Web GOIB)

Technically, the general Spanish building standard also remains decisive. Anyone who builds or carries out a deep refurbishment always operates within the logic of the LOE and the CTE. That is exactly where long-term value retention begins. (Web GOIB)

When a new build is the better solution

A new build offers maximum freedom in spatial concept, building services, energy, floor plan and design clarity. It often makes sense when a plot offers good conditions and the desired use is to be developed afresh without compromise.

When refurbishment offers real added value

A refurbishment can be strong when location, structure and character already bring a great deal of quality. In Mallorca in particular, grown substance can be very valuable in terms of atmosphere. The prerequisite is that the existing building is technically sound and sufficiently clarified in legal terms.

Conversion does not automatically mean less effort

Many owners expect a conversion to be simpler or cheaper than a new build. This is often not the case. Hidden damage, old installations, damp building elements, structural issues, unclear areas or problematic extensions can make an existing building considerably more complex than first thought.

New build, conversion or refurbishment in Mallorca – when is which more sensible?

Principle

It is not the building idea that decides first, but the plot.

Decisive are:

Among other things, the PTIM contains maps of urban development areas, categories of suelo rústico, risk prevention, landscape integration, infrastructure and culturally or naturally relevant routes. This check belongs before any purchase or project decision. (pterritorial.conselldemallorca.es)


When a new build makes sense

When the plot can be built on cleanly in planning-law terms.

When maximum plannability is wanted.

When the existing building offers no architectural, legal or economic advantage.

When a high-quality, long-term concept of use is planned.

When a new build is more economical than a deep core refurbishment.

When the topography is manageable.


When refurbishment makes sense

When the existing building is legal, valuable and approvable.

When the existing building offers a location or grandfathering advantage.

When the interventions can be kept limited.

When the house is atmospherically stronger than a new build.

When refurbishment is thought together with interior design and value retention.


When a conversion makes sense

When the existing building is fundamentally usable but no longer suits the use.

When selective interventions bring great benefit.

When the project remains simpler in permit terms than a new build.


When refurbishment becomes risky

When the legality of the existing building is unclear.

When the building condition is underestimated.

When the desired comfort does not suit the existing building.

When a “small refurbishment” actually becomes a core refurbishment.


When a new build becomes risky

When the plot is only apparently buildable.

When the outdoor areas are underestimated.

When the plot lies in suelo rústico.

When the client looks only at the house price.


Economic decision criteria

A new build is often better when:

Refurbishment is often better when:

Conversion is often better when:


Approval and procedure

New build

Conversion

Refurbishment

Observe CTE and LOE

The Spanish Código Técnico de la Edificación applies to building projects whose documents require a licence or authorisation required by law. (BOE)

The Ley de Ordenación de la Edificación defines the roles of those involved in building, including project author, site manager and execution manager. The director de ejecución de obra monitors the material execution as well as the quality and quantities of the work. (BOE)


Assessing the existing building before any refurbishment

Legal review

Planning review

Technical review

Economic review


Role of the architect, the technical architect and project management

Architect

Technical architect / aparejador – included in jle’s scope of services

Project management / client representation – additional services of the architect at jle

Lawyer

Tax adviser


Typical wrong decisions


Decision formula for clients

New build, when law, plot, budget and use are clear.

Refurbishment, when the existing building, location and character are stronger than the risks.

Conversion, when the substance is good and targeted interventions create the greatest added value.

Demolition or partial new build, when refurbishment is out of proportion technically and economically.

No project start as long as legality, approvability, cost framework and project management have not been reliably clarified.

FAQ

Is refurbishing in Mallorca generally cheaper?

No. Refurbishment can make economic sense, but it is by no means automatically cheaper.

When should demolition be seriously considered?

Whenever the existing building, structure, legalisation and desired use no longer fit together sensibly.

The right decision does not arise from sympathy for the existing building but from an honest assessment.

project examples:

1323 son dc finca Felanitx

1323 finca son dc, felanitx

1710 Finca Na Borras, Mallorca: evening view of the light earth-toned finca with timber pergola, ArchDaily Building of the Year Nominee 2024

1710 finca na borras, cala llombards

1906 new house Calvià Mallorca

1906 new build sol de mallorca

talk to us

Request the guide to building in Mallorca and the Balearics

or

create a jle online checklist

back to the building in Mallorca guide

References

Ley de Ordenación de la Edificación BOE Roles, liability, responsibilities

Código Técnico de la Edificación BOE Technical requirements for new builds and refurbishments

Decreto Ley 3/2024 CAIB Special rules for certain existing-building constellations

Ley 7/2024 CAIB Applicable Balearic framework